| ..:: Legality CV. Cendekiawan Muda Sriwijaya ::.. |
| SK Kemenkumham RI |
Peer Reviewers: Roles and Responsibilities
Reviewers are the backbone of STJHS. A reviewer is an independent expert who is invited to evaluate whether a manuscript is sound, original, ethical and clearly reported, and to help authors improve it. Reviewers are chosen for their subject knowledge and publication record, and they serve voluntarily. The list of reviewers is published periodically to acknowledge their contribution.
Before accepting an invitation, a reviewer should consider whether they have the expertise, time and independence to give a fair review, and should decline if they have a conflict of interest. Reviews must be completed on time, be constructive and specific, and comment respectfully on the work rather than on the authors personally. The reviewer should point to any ethical concerns, such as missing approvals, suspected plagiarism, or data problems, and must keep the manuscript and the review confidential. Reviewers must not share the manuscript with others, use its content for personal advantage, or use AI tools in ways that expose confidential material. If a reviewer wishes to involve a colleague, they must first ask the editor. The recommendation of a reviewer is advisory, and the final decision rests with the editors.
Source: COPE, Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers; Editing Peer Reviews.



.png)
.png)



.png)
.png
)


