Peer Review Process

Every research manuscript submitted to STJHS goes through a structured, confidential peer review process. On arrival, the editorial office checks the submission for completeness, adherence to the author guidelines, scope fit, and similarity with existing literature. Manuscripts that fail these checks may be returned or rejected before external review.

Submissions that pass the initial screening are assigned by the Editor-in-Chief or a handling editor to at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise. The journal uses a [double-blind] model: the identities of authors and reviewers are withheld from each other. Reviewers evaluate the originality, methodological rigor, ethical approval, quality of analysis, and the support that the data give to the conclusions. They are asked to complete their reports within [two to four weeks].

Based on the reports, the editor decides to accept, request minor revision, request major revision, or reject the manuscript. Authors who revise are asked to respond point by point to each comment. Revised manuscripts may be sent back to the original reviewers. Editorial decisions are based on the quality of the work and never on the author's nationality, gender, institution, or personal relationship with the editors. Authors who disagree with a decision may submit a reasoned appeal to the Editor-in-Chief, who will consider it fairly and, where needed, seek additional advice.

Reviewers are expected to follow the conduct described on the Reviewer page, and editors are expected to handle reviews responsibly, including not altering reviewer reports without a justified reason.

Source: COPE, Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers; Editing Peer Reviews; A Short Guide to Ethical Editing for New Editors.