Conflict of Interest

A conflict of interest exists when a financial, personal, professional or institutional relationship could reasonably be seen as influencing the judgment of an author, reviewer or editor. Having a conflict of interest is not misconduct; failing to disclose it is a problem.

Authors must declare all relevant interests at submission, including funding sources, employment, consultancy, and close personal or professional relationships relevant to the work. In legal scholarship, this includes any role as counsel, judge, prosecutor, legislator, government official or party in a case, regulation or institution that the article discusses. If there are none, the manuscript should say so. The declaration is published with the article.

Reviewers must decline an invitation if they have competing interests, for example if they work at the same institution as the authors, have recently collaborated with them, are involved in the matter under discussion, or are direct competitors. Editors must not handle manuscripts in which they have a conflict. In such cases, another editor will manage the manuscript. Editors who submit their own work to LSJ will be excluded from every stage of its handling, and the decision will be made by an independent editor. The same applies to special collections or guest-edited issues, where guest editors must disclose their interests and must not decide on their own submissions.

Source: COPE, A Short Guide to Ethical Editing for New Editors; Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers; Guest Edited Collections.