..:: Submission::..
Colaboration Publisher :
Peer Review Process and Editorial WorkflowThe Journal Of Law And Social Society believes that a healthy, rigorous, and transparent peer review process is critical to the accurate and honest communication of research. We employ a strict Double-Blind Peer Review model. The entire process is designed to prevent bias, ensure academic rigor, and adhere fully to the COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers.
Stage 1: Initial Submission and Desk Review (1-2 Weeks) Upon submission through our online system, the manuscript undergoes an initial evaluation by the Editor-in-Chief and the Managing Editor.
Scope and Formatting Check: The editorial team verifies that the manuscript aligns with the journal's Focus and Scope and strictly follows the Author Guidelines (including APA citation format and word count).
Plagiarism and Originality Screening: The manuscript is scanned using industry-standard anti-plagiarism software (e.g., Turnitin or iThenticate). Manuscripts with a similarity index exceeding 20% (excluding references and block quotes) will be immediately returned to the author or rejected.
Anonymization Check: Editors ensure that the main manuscript file contains no author-identifying information to prepare it for the double-blind review.If the manuscript fails this stage, it receives a "Desk Rejection." If it passes, it moves to the next stage.
Stage 2: Reviewer Assignment The Section Editor assigns the manuscript to a minimum of 2 (two) independent, external peer reviewers who are recognized experts in the manuscript's specific socio-legal subject area.
Conflict of Interest: Reviewers are required to declare any potential conflicts of interest before accepting the invitation to review. Reviewers must not be from the same institution as the authors, nor should they have co-authored publications with the authors in the past three years.
Double-Blind Integrity: The identities of both the authors and the reviewers are strictly concealed from one another throughout the entire process.
Stage 3: The Evaluation Process (4-6 Weeks) Reviewers evaluate the manuscript using a standardized review form. They assess the submission based on the following criteria:
Originality and Contribution: Does the research provide novel insights into law and social society?
Methodological Rigor: Are the socio-legal research methods (normative, empirical, or doctrinal) sound and well-explained?
Ethical Integrity: Is there any suspicion of data fabrication, falsification, or unethical research practices? (Reviewers are instructed to report any suspicions to the Editor immediately, as per COPE guidelines).
Clarity and Argumentation: Are the arguments logical, well-supported by literature, and clearly articulated?
Stage 4: Editorial Decision Once the reviewers submit their reports, the Handling Editor synthesizes the feedback and makes a recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief. The possible decisions are:
Accept Submission: The manuscript is accepted as is (rare).
Revisions Required (Minor): The author must make slight adjustments to citations, language, or minor structural issues within 2 weeks.
Resubmit for Review (Major): The author must undertake significant revisions regarding methodology, data analysis, or fundamental arguments within 4 weeks. The revised manuscript may be sent back to the original reviewers for a second round of evaluation.
Decline Submission: The manuscript is fundamentally flawed, unoriginal, or outside the journal's scope.
Stage 5: Handling Peer Review Manipulation and Appeals The editorial board actively monitors for peer review manipulation (e.g., fake reviewer emails or coordinated citation cartels). Any suspected manipulation will be handled strictly according to the COPE Flowchart on How to recognize potential manipulation of the peer review process. Authors have the right to appeal an editorial decision if they believe it was based on a factual error or reviewer bias. Appeals must be submitted in writing to the Editor-in-Chief, who will initiate a formal, transparent review of the complaint.
COPE Compliance Proof: Our entire peer review architecture is built upon COPE's mandate that "Journals must have clearly described processes for handling both [complaints and appeals], and must adhere to those processes" and that the peer review process must be "transparently described and well managed."
Reference 1: COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers
Reference 2: COPE Overview on Peer Review Models
| ..:: Legality Cendekiawan Muda Sriwijaya ::.. |
| SK Kemenkumham RI |
| ..:: Editorial Menu::.. |
| Editorial Team |
| Reviewer Menu |
Journal Of Law And Social Society (JALASOS)
Publisher : CV. Cendikiawan Muda Sriwijaya
Educational Institution, Research, Consultant, Book and Journal Publishing
Registered by the Ministry of Law and Human Rights of the Republic of Indonesia
On February 22, 2024
Editor In Chief : Dr. Junaidi, SH. MH
Quality Control : Dr. Zainul Arifin, SH. MH
Contact Email: [email protected]
Hubungi : 085378329037
Journal Of Law And Social Society This licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International